PlumResearch
Press office

Why did Netflix cancel 1899?

Take a look at insights and benchmarks prepared by PlumResearch

Key takeaways from the analysis:

We used our Showlabs metrics to look for the reasons behind the 1899 cancellation backed by the viewership data

We compared two similar Netflix Original series by Jantje Friese and Baran bo Odar, 1899 and Dark

In the first 60 days after release, 1899 captured more Unique Viewers (UVs) than Dark in the United States, Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Spain, and Italy

In the US, 1899 had a much stronger start on Netflix, with 11.1M UVs after seven days and 19.2M UVs after 28 days. For comparison, Dark captured 3.9M UVs and 8.6M UVs, respectively

1899 had a 3-5% higher completion rate than Dark, yet both shows fell way behind the 50% benchmark

After analyzing our Get Hooked (GH) metric, we conclude that for viewers of both series, the "point of no return" was two episodes before the finale, considering their respective lengths

See our data and insights in action!

Want to access more in-depth data on 1899 using Showlabs by PlumResearch?
Experience our cutting-edge platform providing detailed insights on SVOD viewership data.

PlumResearch
Powering the entertainment industry with data-driven insights

PlumResearch specializes in precise and granular data measurement of streaming platforms. We have the world's largest online audience panels and provide our clients with insights from over 75+ markets worldwide. Through our main solution, the Showlabs platform, we deliver our clients SVOD data-driven insights to power their business growth. We work with the entertainment industry leaders, helping them to make strategic decisions.

Netflix's decision to cancel some of its shows without disclosing viewership data has left many industry experts questioning their reasoning. Recently, after having only one season available for six weeks, the mystery drama "1899" was canceled, prompting our Team to investigate and analyze the possible reasons behind the decision. 

PlumResearch employed a data-driven approach to analyze key Showlabs metrics and identify possible factors contributing to the show's cancellation. Our findings may offer valuable insights for businesses navigating the ever-changing streaming media industry.

Let's try to uncover why 1899 was canceled by using our exclusive Showlabs viewership data.

What is Showlabs

Showlabs by PlumResearch is the leading platform for SVOD audience measurement.

Showlabs is filled with such reports as:

  • Ranking Report
  • Time Report
  • Popularity Report
  • Cross-Viewing Report
  • Engagement Report
  • Summary Report
  • Reactivation Report
  • Cross-Ranking Report
  • Cross-Platforms Report
  • Availability Report

The first question we asked was:
How did 1899 perform on Netflix compared to Dark?

Why did we choose Dark as a point of comparison? Sharing showrunners Jantje Friese and Baran bo Odar, and the mystery and suspense genre, both series feature comparable stylistic and thematic elements while exploring supernatural themes and the complexities of human relationships. By examining the viewership data for both shows, we hoped to better understand what led to the cancellation of 1899.

In the following sections, we'll take a closer look at our findings and provide insights into what may have contributed to the abrupt cancellation of 1899.

1899 and Dark global performance

To look at both shows’ global performance, we compared the viewership numbers of “1899” and “Dark” in the United States, Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Spain, and Italy in the first 60 days since the series’ release. As a result, we can share how “1899” outperformed “Dark” in all analyzed countries.

Figure 1. 1899 and Dark — 60-Day performance on Netflix in the United States, Germany, France, United Kingdom, Spain, Italy

Case study:
Viewership of 1899 in the USA

Let’s now focus on the United States and look at our standard Showlabs metrics. We compared both series' Unique Viewers (UVs) since the release date to discover that “1899” had a much stronger start on Netflix.  From the first day of its availability, the series captured around 1.6M Unique Viewers (UVs), with a peak of more than 2.8M UVs on day 5! None of the three seasons of “Dark” beat that number.

Figure 2. 1899 and Dark — Unique Viewers (UV) Since Release Date, United States

We dug deeper by comparing Unique Viewers (UVs) after 7 and 28 days on Netflix.

Figure 3. 1899 and Dark — 7-, and 28-Day Unique Viewers (UVs), United States

Is the low Completion Rate one of the reasons behind the 1899 cancelation?

By Completion Rate (CR), we mean a percentage of Unique Viewers (UVs) who fully watched all of the episodes of a single season to all Unique Viewers (UVs) who fully watched the first episode in the season.

Figure 4. 1899 and Dark — 7 and 28 days Completion Rate (%), United States

1899 had a higher Completion Rate (CR) than the first season of Dark!

Well, evidently, the Completion Rate speaks in favor of “1899”. Nevertheless, CR at the level of 30% is not as impressive a result as it could be. Let's look at other scripted series debuting on Netflix around the same time as "1899.”

Figure 5. Inside Man,  Manifest and Wednesday — 7 and 28 days Completion Rate (%), United States

The Completion Rates of 1899 and Dark are close. Still, both fall short compared to the CR of Inside Man S1, Manifest S4, and Wednesday, where all three exceeded the 50% benchmark. Comparing the CR metrics, we can assume that the low completion rate might have impacted the 1899's cancellation.

The Get Hooked metric helps us determine how “addictive” the show was! The answer to the question “Why 1899 was canceled” may also be hidden here.

We used our Get Hooked (GH) metric to determine the earliest possible episode where at least 70% of the episode viewers finished the whole season.

Figure 6. 1899 and Dark — Get Hooked (GH) metric, the United States

The US audience found 1899 more addictive than Dark. While Dark took eight episodes to complete the season within a week of its release, 1899 only took six. However, considering their respective lengths, both series reached their "point of no return" two episodes before the finale. We may conclude that, in our case, the GH results were comparable, but only among their quite specific audiences.

But how "addictive" was the competition?

To put both titles in context, we also checked the Get Hooked metric of Inside Man S1, Manifest S4, and Wednesday.

Figure 7. Inside Man,  Manifest and Wednesday — Get Hooked (GH) metric, the United States

Our data shows that viewers who watched 1899 were more likely to be drawn into other titles available on Netflix at the same time. For example, the viewers following the adventures of young Wednesday Addams needed to watch at least four of eight episodes to stay until the show's finale. Inside Man, the thriller series starring Stanley Tucci and David Tennant, had an even better result; most viewers got addicted after the third episode. 

Returning to our central question:
Why did Netflix sink 1899 right after the first season, although the show's performance was strong when analyzing the viewership data?

There may be a few possible reasons:

Despite the general good audience results, 1899 was popular in a very specific viewer community. It is safer for producers and distributors to put their bets on the content, attracting more diverse viewers

Good basic metrics, like Total Views and Total Hours Watched, are not enough in the fragmented and saturated SVOD landscape today

Getting the audience hooked faster and stronger is challenging for content producers and distributors—precise data on more advanced audience habits is necessary here

Other Netflix content released around the 1899 premiere performed better in the same period. Streaming platforms, Netflix included, need to be very selective in deciding where to put their future investment focus, especially when dealing with big-budget productions like 1899 that require significant financial resources

Empower your SVOD content production, sales, negotiations, acquisition, and planning with Showlabs

We will help you validate the actual monetary value of your content and identify its strengths and weaknesses locally and globally.